- Archaeological News
-
Gediminas’ Tower and the remains of the Upper Castle in Vilnius, Lithuania. A new isotope study suggests that changes in agricultural practices during the early modern period may have influenced the chemical signatures preserved in human remains.
Image Credit:
BigHead, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Manured Crops May Explain a Mysterious Dietary Shift in Early Modern Lithuania
A rise in nitrogen isotope values found in the bones of people who lived in Lithuania after about AD 1500 may not simply mean that they were eating more meat. A new study suggests that changes in farming, particularly more systematic use of animal manure on cereal fields, may have altered the chemical signature of crops and passed that signal into the people who consumed them.
Researchers examine a long-running question in archaeological diet reconstruction. Scientists often measure nitrogen isotope ratios, expressed as δ15N, in human bone collagen. Higher values are commonly associated with greater consumption of animal protein because nitrogen isotope values generally increase along the food chain. But crops grown on heavily manured soils can also acquire elevated δ15N values.
Previous research had identified a marked rise in δ15N among people in Lithuania during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, particularly in Vilnius. This was often interpreted as evidence for increased consumption of meat and other animal products and, in some cases, linked to wealthier diets. Yet elevated values also appeared among ordinary urban residents, raising questions about whether animal protein alone could explain the pattern.
To investigate, the researchers assembled isotope data spanning thousands of years, from the Late Mesolithic to the eighteenth century. Their dataset includes 285 cereal samples, 291 animal samples and 584 human individuals from 71 burial sites. The plant material included barley, rye, wheat, oats and millet, with 100 rye grains newly analyzed for the study.
The strongest change appeared between the medieval and Early Modern periods. Average δ15N values in barley increased from about 4.6‰ to 6.5‰, while rye rose from roughly 3.4‰ to 5.2‰. Across cereals as a whole, the increase was around 1.8–1.9‰ and was statistically significant.
Human values changed in the same general direction. Among commoners, average δ15N rose from about 9.7‰ in the medieval period to 10.8‰ in the Early Modern period. The animal record, however, did not show a comparable overall rise. This difference is important because it suggests that the shift was not simply produced by changes affecting livestock or by a universal rise across the entire terrestrial food chain.
The researchers argue that intensified crop management offers a plausible explanation. Manuring raises nitrogen isotope values in plants, particularly in the grain consumed by humans. Livestock, meanwhile, may have eaten more wild vegetation, straw and chaff, which can carry lower isotope values than the grain itself. As a result, heavily manured crops could raise human δ15N values without producing an equally strong signal in animal bones.
The timing also coincides with major changes in Lithuanian agriculture. In 1557, the Grand Duchy of Lithuania introduced the Volok Reform, which reorganized landholding, imposed a more regular three-field rotation system and encouraged more systematic management of agricultural land. The reform also promoted practices that made manure collection and field fertilization more efficient.
Environmental explanations were also considered. Temperature, rainfall, soil conditions and water stress can influence plant nitrogen values. However, the researchers found no evidence that changing water availability alone explains the Early Modern increase, while many of the analyzed grains came from broadly comparable soils in eastern Lithuania. This strengthens, but does not prove, the case for human agricultural practices as a major factor.
The authors stress that intensified manuring probably does not explain the entire rise in human isotope values. Changes in living conditions, access to animal foods, markets and religious dietary practices may also have played a role. The cereal and human shifts were similar but not perfectly synchronized.
The broader implication reaches beyond Lithuania. Archaeologists frequently reconstruct ancient diets by comparing human isotope values mainly with those of animals from the same region. The new study argues that this can be misleading when crop management changes over time. Incorporating archaeological cereal data may therefore help distinguish a population that genuinely ate more animal protein from one whose staple grains simply carried a stronger isotopic signature because farmers fertilized their fields more intensively.
Published on: 20-11-2026
Edited by: Abdulmnam Samakie